Breaking News

Particular Report: FTX’s Bankman-Fried begged for a rescue whilst he revealed enormous holes in agency’s books

Particular Report: FTX’s Bankman-Fried begged for a rescue whilst he revealed enormous holes in agency’s books

  • FTX founder sought to lift $7 billion from buyers together with Sequoia, Apollo, TPG, three sources say
  • FTX additionally turned to Nomura and Saudi wealth fund – sources
  • FTX and buying and selling affiliate Alameda, nominally impartial, each listed identical property on their books – investor shows
  • Information seen by Reuters present FTX diverted massive share of payment revenue to Alameda, posted huge loss earlier this 12 months

Nov 16 (Reuters) – As prospects withdrew billions of {dollars} from crypto alternate FTX one frantic Sunday this month, founder Sam Bankman-Fried labored the telephones in a futile bid to lift $7 billion in emergency funds.

Hunkered in his Bahamas condo, Bankman-Fried toiled via the night time, calling a few of the world’s greatest buyers, together with Sequoia Capital, Apollo World Administration Inc (APO.N) and TPG Inc (TPG.O), in response to three folks with data of the matter.

Sequoia was amongst buyers that lined up solely months earlier than to pump cash into Bankman-Fried’s empire. However not now. Sequoia was shocked on the amount of cash Bankman-Fried wanted to save lots of FTX, in response to the sources, whereas Apollo first requested for extra data, solely to later decline. Each companies and TPG declined to remark for this text.

In the long run, the calls got here to naught and FTX filed for chapter on Nov. 11, leaving an estimated 1 million prospects and different buyers dealing with complete losses within the billions of {dollars}. The collapse reverberated throughout the crypto world and despatched bitcoin and different digital property plummeting.

Some particulars of what occurred at FTX have already emerged: Reuters reported Bankman-Fried secretly used $10 billion in buyer funds to prop up his buying and selling enterprise, for example, and that no less than $1 billion of these deposits had vanished.

Now, a overview of dozens of firm paperwork and interviews with present and former executives and buyers present essentially the most complete image to date of how Bankman-Fried, the 30-year-old son of Stanford College professors, grew to become one of many richest males on the earth in simply a few years, then got here crashing down.

The paperwork, reported right here for the primary time, embrace monetary statements, enterprise updates, firm messages and letters to buyers. They, together with the interviews, reveal that:

— In shows to buyers, a few of the identical property appeared concurrently on the steadiness sheets of FTX and of Bankman-Fried’s buying and selling agency, Alameda Analysis – regardless of claims by FTX that Alameda operated independently.

— Certainly one of Bankman-Fried’s shut aides tweaked FTX’s accounting software program. This enabled Bankman-Fried to cover the switch of buyer cash from FTX to Alameda. A screenshot of FTX’s book-keeping system confirmed that even after the huge buyer withdrawals, some $10 billion in deposits remained, plus a surplus of $1.5 billion. This led staff to imagine wrongly that FTX was on a stable monetary footing.

— FTX made about $400 million in “software program royalty” funds to Alameda over time. Alameda used the funds to purchase FTX’s digital coin FTT, lowering provide of the coin and supporting its value.

— Within the second quarter of this 12 months, FTX posted a $161 million loss. Bankman-Fried, in the meantime, had spent some $2 billion on acquisitions.

— As Bankman-Fried tried to rescue FTX in its frantic closing days, he sought emergency investments from monetary behemoths in Saudi Arabia and Japan – and was joined at his Bahamas headquarters by his regulation professor father.

Bankman-Fried instructed Reuters in an electronic mail that as a result of a “complicated inner account,” Alameda’s leverage was considerably greater than he believed it was. He added that FTX processed roughly $6 billion of consumer withdrawals.

He stated FTX and Alameda collectively made a revenue of roughly $1.5 billion in 2021, which was greater than all the bills put collectively of each organizations since their founding. “I used to be sadly unable to speak a lot of what was occurring to the broader firm in actual time as a result of a lot of what I posted in Slack appeared on Twitter quickly after,” he added.

FTX didn’t reply to questions for this text.

The U.S. Division of Justice, Securities and Alternate Fee and Commodity Futures Buying and selling Fee are actually all investigating FTX, together with the way it dealt with buyer funds, Reuters has reported. The collapse has shaken investor confidence in cryptocurrencies and led to calls from lawmakers and others for larger regulation of the trade. The CFTC and DOJ declined to remark for this text. The SEC didn’t reply.


Born in 1992, Bankman-Fried grew up round Stanford College’s Palo Alto-area campus, the place each his mother and father taught on the regulation college. He landed on the Massachusetts Institute of Expertise, the place he studied math and physics and embraced the thought of efficient altruism, a motion that encourages folks to prioritize donations to charities.

After graduating from MIT in 2014, he took a job on Wall Avenue with a quantitative buying and selling agency. Bankman-Fried based Alameda Analysis three years later, billing it as “a crypto quant buying and selling agency.”

Rejected initially by enterprise buyers, he cobbled collectively loans and assembled a workforce of younger merchants and programmers, lots of them sleeping and dealing in a small walkup condo within the San Francisco space, in response to a profile that later appeared on the web site of FTX investor Sequoia.

Alameda discovered early buying and selling success by arbitraging cryptocurrency costs on worldwide markets, with half of income going to charity, in response to the identical profile. By 2019, the corporate dealt with $55 million for shoppers, an Alameda firm booklet stated. Reuters couldn’t independently affirm these particulars.

The booklet flagged the dangers of crypto buying and selling, notably how sudden gross sales of tokens may set off a “domino impact” that will result in a “cascading set of liquidity failures.” It famous that “nothing basic” backed bitcoin’s worth.

Utilizing income from Alameda, Bankman-Fried launched FTX in 2019. His intention was to construct an “FTX Superapp” that mixed cryptocurrency buying and selling, betting markets, inventory buying and selling, banking, and peer-to-peer and enterprise funds, in response to an FTX advertising and marketing doc from earlier this 12 months.

The corporate’s progress over the following two years was solely surpassed by his imaginative and prescient.

FTX’s revenues grew from $10 million in 2019 to $1 billion in 2021. From nearly nothing in 2019, FTX dealt with about 10% of world crypto buying and selling this 12 months, a September doc reveals. It spent roughly $2 billion shopping for corporations, the doc reveals.

Reuters Graphics Reuters Graphics

In an undated doc, titled ‘FTX Roadmap 2022,’ the corporate laid out its targets for the following 5 to 10 years. It hoped to be “the most important international monetary alternate,” with $30 billion in annual income, greater than what U.S. retail brokerage large Constancy Investments earned in revenues final 12 months.

In October 2021, Bankman-Fried, then 29 years outdated, landed on the duvet of Forbes, which pegged his web value at $26.5 billion – the twenty fifth richest particular person in America. FTX stated on its web site that “FTX, its associates, and its staff have donated over $10m to assist save lives, stop struggling, and guarantee a brighter future.”

Bankman-Fried’s private funds recommend he lived frugally for a billionaire. A monetary assertion reviewed by Reuters reveals that for 2021, he drew an annual wage of $200,000, declared $1 million in actual property property, and spent $50,000 on private bills.

However within the Bahamas, his life-style was extra luxurious than his funds confirmed. At one level, he lived in a penthouse overlooking the Caribbean, valued at nearly $40 million, in response to two individuals who labored with FTX.

Bankman-Fried instructed Reuters he lived in a home with 9 different colleagues. For his staff, he stated FTX offered free meals and an “in-house Uber-like” service across the island.


This 12 months started with FTX seemingly in every single place.

Its brand was emblazoned on a significant sports activities enviornment in Miami and on Main League Baseball umpire uniforms. Sports activities stars and celebrities together with Tom Brady, Gisele Bundchen and Steph Curry grew to become companions in selling the corporate. None of them commented for this text. Bankman-Fried grew to become a daily presence in Washington, donating tens of tens of millions of {dollars} to politicians and lobbying lawmakers on crypto markets.

FTX was additionally planning partnerships with a few of the world’s largest corporations. An FTX doc from June 2022, which has not been beforehand reported, reveals a listing of FTX’s “choose companions” for business-to-business (B2B) companies. Potential companions included retail large Walmart Inc (WMT.N), social media titan Meta Platforms Inc (META.O), payment-system supplier Stripe, and monetary web site Yahoo! Finance, in response to the doc.

A Yahoo spokesperson stated, “Whereas we had been in very early levels of a potential partnership with FTX, nothing was near completion when the occasions of final week occurred.”

An individual with data of the matter stated Stripe has no contract with FTX to allow Stripe customers to just accept crypto funds. Walmart did not reply to a request for remark a couple of proposed partnership with FTX for worker investing. Meta too did not remark about discussions to make FTX a digital-wallet supplier for Instagram customers.

Traders cherished Bankman-Fried’s ambition. FTX had already obtained greater than $2 billion from backers together with Sequoia, SoftBank Group Corp (9984.T), BlackRock Inc (BLK.N) and Temasek. In January, FTX raised an extra $400 million, valuing the enterprise at $32 billion.

FTX anticipated to take its worldwide and U.S. companies public, an investor due-diligence doc from this June stated. The doc is reported right here for the primary time.

On the peak of his powers, Bankman-Fried urged the crypto trade to assist governments form legal guidelines to oversee it, saying FTX’s objective was to grow to be “one of the crucial regulated exchanges on the earth.” “FTX has the cleanest model in crypto,” it proclaimed earlier this 12 months.

Behind his fast progress, there was a secret Bankman-Fried stored from most different staff: he had dipped into buyer funds to pay for a few of his initiatives, in response to firm paperwork and folks briefed on FTX’s funds. Doing so was explicitly barred within the alternate’s phrases of use, which affirmed person deposits “shall always stay with you.”

FTX generated 2 cents in charges for each $100 traded, paperwork seen by Reuters present, reaping lots of of tens of millions of {dollars} in income by 2021. Nonetheless, FTX barely broke even throughout its first two years, 2019 and 2020. It generated round $450 million in revenue in 2021, when crypto markets boomed, but it surely slumped to a $161 million loss within the second quarter of this 12 months, in response to monetary data, that are reported right here for the primary time.

A number of the $10 billion in eliminated prospects’ cash went to cowl losses that Alameda sustained earlier this 12 months on a collection of bailouts, together with in failed crypto lender Voyager Digital, in response to the three FTX sources briefed on the corporate’s funds.

FTX additionally financed acquisitions corresponding to the acquisition in Could of a $640 million stake in buying and selling platform Robinhood Markets Inc (HOOD.O). Robinhood did not reply to a request for remark.

Bankman-Fried instructed Reuters he didn’t imagine that Alameda had substantial losses, together with on Voyager, with out offering additional particulars.

Round $1 billion of the $10 billion sum is just not accounted for amongst Alameda’s property, Reuters reported on Friday. Reuters has not been capable of hint these lacking funds.

In line with the three FTX sources, solely Bankman-Fried’s innermost circle of associates knew about his use of consumer deposits: his co-founder and chief expertise officer, Gary Wang; the pinnacle of engineering, Nishad Singh; and Caroline Ellison, chief govt of Alameda. Wang and Singh each labored with Bankman-Fried at Alameda beforehand.

Wang, Singh and Ellison didn’t return requests for remark.

To hide the transfers of buyer funds to Alameda, Wang, a former Google software program developer, constructed a backdoor in FTX’s book-keeping software program, the folks stated.

Bankman-Fried typically instructed staff tasked with monitoring the corporate’s financials that the book-keeping system was “the final word supply of fact” in regards to the firm’s accounts, two of the folks stated. However the backdoor, recognized solely to his most trusted lieutenants, allowed Alameda to withdraw crypto deposits with out triggering inner pink flags, they stated.

FTX additionally had a vulnerability: its bespoke cryptocurrency.

Shortly after its launch, FTX launched its personal digital token, known as FTT, described on its web site because the alternate’s “spine.” Employees may choose to obtain pay and bonuses within the token, and lots of of them amassed fortunes in FTT as its worth exploded in 2021, in response to the three present and former executives. One govt invested all their financial savings in FTT, value tens of millions of {dollars}, the chief stated, “due to loyalty to Sam.”

In line with a June 2022 due diligence doc Bankman-Fried despatched to a possible investor and the corporate’s monetary data, FTX paid $400 million to an Alameda subsidiary since 2019 as “software program royalty” funds for growth work. The subsidiary used the funds to purchase FTT and take away the digital tokens from provide, so supporting the value.

FTX disclosed on its web site that it was utilizing a part of its buying and selling charges to purchase FTT. It didn’t reveal the association with Alameda.

Over time, Alameda amassed an enormous holding of FTT, valued at round $6 billion earlier than final week, in response to a steadiness sheet later despatched to buyers. It used the FTT reserves to safe company loans, folks aware of its funds stated. This meant that Bankman-Fried’s enterprise empire was depending on the token.

That little-known holding grew to become Bankman-Fried’s undoing.


On Nov. 2, information outlet CoinDesk reported a leaked steadiness sheet disclosing Alameda’s reliance on FTT. The top of the world’s largest crypto alternate – Bankman-Fried’s chief rival – pounced on that report. Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao, citing “latest revelations,” stated Binance would promote its whole FTT holding as a result of “threat administration.”

Bankman-Fried retorted on Twitter that Zhao was spreading “false rumors.” In a since-deleted tweet, he wrote: “FTX has sufficient to cowl all consumer holdings. We don’t make investments consumer property.”

Nonetheless, FTT got here below intense promoting stress, forcing Alameda to purchase extra of the tokens in an try and stabilize the value, an individual with data of the trades stated. Prospects panicked and rushed to withdraw deposits from FTX, with over $100 million flowing out of the agency every hour that Sunday, firm paperwork reviewed by Reuters present.

In his electronic mail to Reuters, Bankman-Fried stated, “To my data, Alameda didn’t purchase very a lot FTT throughout the crash to stabilize it.”

Employees initially remained calm. The finance workforce may nonetheless see ample property on the book-keeping portal as of final week. About $10 billion in consumer deposits remained, with a $1.5 billion surplus to cowl any additional withdrawals, in response to a screenshot of the database seen by Reuters.

In actuality, these funds had been gone.

A number of hours after Zhao’s Sunday tweet, Bankman-Fried has instructed Reuters, he gathered his lieutenants Wang and Singh at his condo to resolve on a plan. It was a “tough weekend,” he messaged workers on Slack that night, however “we’re chugging alongside.”

The next day, he summoned a number of different senior managers to his dwelling to affix Wang and Singh. He broke the information to them: FTX was nearly out of cash.

This account of the scramble that ensued is predicated on interviews with three present and former FTX executives briefed by prime workers and paperwork that Reuters reviewed.

Bankman-Fried confirmed the executives spreadsheets that exposed there was a $10 billion gap in FTX’s funds – as a result of buyer deposits had been transferred to Alameda and principally spent on different property. The executives had been shocked. Certainly one of them instructed Bankman-Fried the spreadsheet presentation contradicted what FTX instructed regulators about its use of consumer funds.

To make up the shortfall, they calculated that Alameda may promote round $3 billion of the property inside hours, primarily cash held in firm buying and selling accounts on different crypto exchanges. The remaining would take days or even weeks to dump as a result of it was arduous to commerce these property. And FTX urgently wanted an extra $7 billion in money to outlive.

So started Bankman-Fried’s seek for a savior.

Whereas cash continued to empty away from FTX, the three sources instructed Reuters, he and his aides labored via the night time, contacting a couple of dozen potential buyers.

He turned to the crypto neighborhood, too, ringing up the group behind Tether, the world’s largest stablecoin, and asking for a mortgage. His father, Joseph Bankman, a Stanford Regulation professor, additionally arrived to advise his son. Bankman didn’t reply to a request for remark. In return for any funding, Bankman-Fried pledged to buyers most of Alameda’s property, together with its holding of FTT, alongside together with his personal 75% stake in FTX. However nobody got here via with a suggestion.

One of many buyers who turned down Bankman-Fried stated his numbers had been “very amateurish,” with out elaborating. One other pink flag was that the spreadsheets confirmed ties between FTX and Alameda, the investor stated.

Round 3 a.m., Bankman-Fried resorted to Zhao, his archrival at Binance. Zhao, extensively recognized by the initials CZ, got here to the telephone. Just a few hours later, Zhao despatched over a non-binding letter of intent to amass, which Bankman-Fried signed. The pair tweeted a joint announcement later that morning.

For many FTX staff, this was the primary they heard in regards to the firm’s dire scenario. “Simply full disbelief and emotions of betrayal,” Zane Tackett, FTX’s head of institutional gross sales, wrote on Twitter the day after. He declined to remark.

Tackett and a few others resigned. “I can not do it any extra,” one other FTX workforce member texted colleagues.

To worsen the ache, the value of the FTT token crashed 80% inside three hours of the information, shrinking Alameda’s property additional and wiping out many staff’ web value. The chief with tens of millions of {dollars} in FTT stated watching it collapse “was like seeing my world diminishing.”

Bankman-Fried pleaded for workers’ forgiveness on Slack, saying he “fucked up” however that the Binance deal allowed them to “combat one other day.” Lower than 30 hours later, Binance pulled out, citing its due diligence. Sequoia then wrote off its $150 million funding in FTX.

Scrambling to discover a savior, Bankman-Fried expanded his search all over the world. “I’ll hold preventing,” he messaged workers.

He sought to steer officers at main monetary establishments corresponding to Saudi Arabia’s Public Funding Fund and Japanese funding financial institution Nomura Holdings Inc (8604.T) to take a position, in response to a message he despatched on Thursday to advisors, together with two different folks aware of the talks. These appeals are reported right here for the primary time. PIF and Nomura didn’t remark.

Bankman-Fried additionally tried to get a gaggle of crypto companies to every pitch in $1 billion. However a steadiness sheet FTX despatched to buyers, exhibiting solely $900 million in liquid property, spooked them, in response to two folks aware of the matter.

By Friday, when FTX filed for chapter in the US, “we had been all doomed,” an govt stated.

Reuters Graphics Reuters Graphics
Reuters Graphics Reuters Graphics

Reporting by Angus Berwick and Anirban Sen in NEW YORK, Elizabeth Howcroft in LONDON and Lawrence Delevingne in BOSTON; extra reporting by Tom Wilson in LONDON, Greg Roumeliotis in NEW YORK and Hannah Lang in WASHINGTON; enhancing by Paritosh Bansal and Janet McBride

Our Requirements: The Thomson Reuters Belief Rules.

Elizabeth Howcroft

Thomson Reuters

Studies on the intersection of finance and expertise, together with cryptocurrencies, NFTs, digital worlds and the cash driving “Web3”.

Leave a Reply